What makes a tournament truly legendary?

What makes a chess tournament great? Is it the strength of the field? The historical stakes? The quality of the games? Or the storylines that echo through chess history for decades?

In a recent episode of Dojo Talks, the team tackled one of the most ambitious questions in chess history: What are the 10 greatest chess tournaments of all time? Joined by TheChessNerd, the discussion ranged from 19th-century classics to brutal Soviet-era candidates and modern super tournaments, debating not just which events mattered, but why they mattered.

This wasn’t just a list—it was a deep dive into the soul of competitive chess.

Why Tournaments Matter in Chess History

Unlike world championship matches, tournaments give us something unique:

• Multiple elite players clashing in a single arena
• Stylistic battles across generations
• Breakout performances and career-defining collapses
• And, sometimes, the birth of entirely new ideas

Many of the tournaments discussed didn’t just crown winners—they changed the direction of chess.

London 1851 – The Birth of International Chess

Every story has an origin, and for tournament chess, it begins here.

London 1851 was the first international chess tournament ever held. Organized by Howard Staunton during the Great Exhibition, it brought together the strongest players of the era and introduced the idea that chess could be contested on a global stage.

Adolf Anderssen’s victory helped establish him as the world’s leading player and set the stage for future legends like Paul Morphy. Without London 1851, the entire concept of elite international competition might never have taken root.

Hastings 1895 – The First Modern Super Tournament

If London 1851 was the beginning, Hastings 1895 was the explosion.

This event featured nearly every top player of the time: Lasker, Steinitz, Tarrasch, Chigorin—and an unknown American named Harry Nelson Pillsbury, who shocked the world by winning the tournament outright.

It was long, grueling, stacked, and full of fighting chess. Many consider Hastings 1895 the first truly modern super tournament—where depth, endurance, and preparation all mattered.

St. Petersburg 1914 – When Legends Collided

Few tournaments in history can boast a lineup like St. Petersburg 1914:

• Emanuel Lasker
• José Raúl Capablanca
• Alexander Alekhine
• Siegbert Tarrasch
• Frank Marshall
• Akiba Rubinstein
• Aron Nimzowitsch

This was a generational showdown. Lasker’s late surge to win the final stage, including his famous Exchange Ruy Lopez victory over Capablanca, is one of the most iconic moments in tournament history.

It wasn’t just strong. It was mythic.

AVRO 1938 – The Strongest Field Ever Assembled

If you care about pure strength of field, AVRO 1938 is hard to beat.

Eight players. All elite. Multiple world champions. No filler.

Alekhine, Capablanca, Botvinnik, Keres, Fine, Euwe, Reshevsky—this tournament was designed to answer one question: Who is the best player in the world?

It also carried massive historical weight, as it took place on the eve of World War II, with several careers forever altered by what followed. Keres’ brilliant performance remains one of the great “what if” stories in chess.

The 1948 World Championship Tournament – Chess After the War

After Alekhine’s death, chess needed a new champion—and a new beginning.

The 1948 World Championship tournament in The Hague and Moscow brought together Botvinnik, Smyslov, Keres, Reshevsky, and Euwe in a unique quintuple round-robin to decide the next king of chess.

It wasn’t just about the title. It was about rebuilding international chess after the devastation of World War II. Botvinnik’s victory ushered in the Soviet era of dominance.

Zurich 1953 – The Ultimate Candidates Marathon

If you love endurance, drama, and legendary books, Zurich 1953 stands alone.

15 players.
28 rounds.
210 games.
Two classic tournament books.
Endless legends.

Smyslov, Bronstein, Keres, Reshevsky, Najdorf, Geller, Petrosian… this was a brutal, beautiful grind that produced some of the most studied games in history. It’s not just a tournament—it’s a monument.

Candidates 1959 – Tal’s Meteoric Rise

The 1959 Candidates Tournament (Bled–Zagreb–Belgrade) is the stuff of legend.

A young Mikhail Tal tore through the field with fearless attacking chess, earning the right to challenge Botvinnik and becoming the youngest world champion in history soon after.

It also featured a teenage Bobby Fischer, giving the world its first real glimpse of the storm that was coming.

This tournament wasn’t just great—it was electric.

Portorož Interzonal 1958 – Fischer Arrives

Before Fischer became Fischer, there was Portorož 1958.

At just 15 years old, Bobby Fischer qualified for the Candidates, becoming the youngest grandmaster in history at the time. The tournament marked the moment when the chess world realized: this kid is different.

It’s one of the great breakout events in sports history.

San Luis 2005 – Topalov’s Rampage

In the modern era, San Luis 2005 stands out for one reason: Veselin Topalov’s dominance.

He didn’t just win—he crushed the field in the second half of the tournament, leaving no doubt who the best player in the room was. Love the format or hate it, his performance was unforgettable.

Candidates 2013 – Magnus Takes the Throne

Every era has a turning point. For modern chess, it’s London 2013.

Magnus Carlsen entered as the world’s top-rated player. He left as the challenger to the world championship—and soon after, the face of the game.

The final round drama, with both Magnus and Kramnik losing yet Magnus still qualifying, only added to the legend. This was the moment when potential became destiny.

So… What Makes a Tournament “Great”?

From the Dojo discussion, a few themes emerged:

• Strength of field – are the best players actually there?
• Historical stakes – does it decide a champion, a challenger, or a new era?
• Cultural impact – did it change how chess is played or understood?
• Endurance and struggle – short events feel different from two-month wars
• Storylines – rise of legends, falls of giants, and everything in between

Great tournaments aren’t just about who wins. They’re about what changes because of them.

Final Thoughts

What makes this topic so compelling is that there’s no single “correct” list. Every era has its heroes. Every fan has their bias. Some love purity of competition, others love historical drama, and others just want the longest, bloodiest fight possible.

But one thing is clear:

These tournaments didn’t just crown champions.

They shaped chess history.

And that’s what makes them timeless.

Make sure to follow the DojoTalks podcast

Check Out ChessDojo.Club To Improve Your Chess